Mary Yarmirr and Croker Island clans secure recognition of sea Country rights

Anniversary tracker

11 October 2001

In a case led by Mary Yarmirr and Croker Island clans, the High Court upheld recognition of non-exclusive native title to surrounding waters.

Taking sea Country to court

On 11 October 2001, the High Court delivered its decision in the Croker Island sea Country case. Mary Yarmirr, an executive member of the Northern Land Council, led the claim with Croker Island clans. The ruling upheld recognition of non-exclusive native title in waters around the island, off the Northern Territory coast. The case required Australian law to consider rights held in relation to the sea, rather than treating it simply as the space beyond the shore.

What recognition covered

The determination recognised rights that included access and the taking of resources for personal, domestic or non-commercial communal needs. It also dealt with activities such as visiting and protecting places of cultural importance. The legal question was not whether Croker Island people had a relationship with the water. The court was deciding which rights under traditional laws and customs Australian law could recognise as native title.

The finding was also about places beneath the surface. The judgment addressed waters and the seabed within the claim area, showing why older descriptions of native title solely as rights over land could not capture what this case was about. It did not mean every sea Country claim would have the same outcome; the rights still had to be established by the claimants’ own evidence.

Where the court drew a line

The Court did not recognise a right of exclusive possession over the claimed waters. Public rights of navigation and fishing, and the passage of foreign ships, were relevant to that limit. ‘Non-exclusive’ is therefore an important part of the result: Croker Island clans gained recognition of rights that could exist alongside public rights, rather than a general power to exclude others from the waters.

Mary Yarmirr’s legacy

The Northern Land Council identifies Yarmirr’s leadership as a milestone in its own history. Her case gave other island and coastal communities a precedent when seeking recognition of sea Country rights. It is worth remembering both elements of the result: her leadership helped establish that native title can exist at sea, and the decision left legal limits on what that title could contain in this case.

Sources and further reading

Online sources

High Court of Australia: The Commonwealth v Yarmirr Decision date and reasons for recognition of non-exclusive native title at sea.
Read the source

Northern Land Council history Identifies Yarmirr’s leadership with Croker Island clans and the importance of the result.
Read the source

Back to the First Nations calendar

Share this story

You’re welcome to share this event by email, on social media, or with your school, workplace and community. Include its context and a link to the full story.

Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email
View suggested text to share

Facebook and LinkedIn share the link; copy the introduction to add context to your post. For Instagram, copy the text and link to use in your own post or Story.