Murrandoo Yanner wins a landmark ruling on traditional hunting

Anniversary tracker

7 October 1999

The High Court upheld Gangalidda man Murrandoo Yanner’s right to hunt in accordance with traditional law and custom in the circumstances of his case.

A challenge from the Gulf

On 7 October 1999, the High Court ruled in favour of Murrandoo Yanner, a Gangalidda man from Queensland’s Gulf of Carpentaria. He had been prosecuted after taking two young crocodiles without a licence. His defence was that he was exercising a right under Gangalidda traditional law and custom. The ruling dealt with the relationship between that right, Queensland wildlife law and the Commonwealth Native Title Act.

How his case reached the High Court

Yanner succeeded in the Mount Isa Magistrates Court. Queensland appealed, and the Queensland Court of Appeal overturned that outcome. Yanner took the case to the High Court. The Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation remembers the case as one brought by a former chief executive of its own organisation, who put a local question about traditional hunting before the country’s highest court.

Regulating a right is not the same as extinguishing it

The High Court distinguished a government’s regulation of fauna from ownership of every wild animal. The fact that Queensland regulated the taking of wildlife did not, in itself, put an end to the native title right at issue. Under the Commonwealth law, the licence requirement did not apply to Yanner in the circumstances established in the case. This was not a ruling that all hunting restrictions had disappeared or that every kind of hunting was exempt.

A useful way to read the result is to separate three matters: whether a traditional right existed, whether earlier legislation had extinguished it, and whether a particular licence requirement applied to this exercise of it. Yanner’s case turned on each of those questions. The ruling would have a different reach if it were described simply as a general permission to hunt protected wildlife.

Why the decision is remembered

For Yanner, the decision settled a prosecution that challenged the way he exercised Gangalidda rights. For other native title holders, it helped make an important distinction clearer: a law controlling how an activity occurs does not always erase the underlying right. The judgment shows why the particular traditional law and custom, purpose of the activity, and wording of the relevant legislation all matter.

Sources and further reading

Online sources

High Court of Australia: Yanner v Eaton Decision date, legal issues and judgment.
Read the source

Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation: Our Story Community organisation’s account of Yanner, Gangalidda rights and the case.
Read the source

Government of Western Australia: Native title chronology Independent institutional summary of the decision’s effect.
Read the source

Back to the First Nations calendar

Share this story

You’re welcome to share this event by email, on social media, or with your school, workplace and community. Include its context and a link to the full story.

Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email
View suggested text to share

Facebook and LinkedIn share the link; copy the introduction to add context to your post. For Instagram, copy the text and link to use in your own post or Story.